Clinically Obese Woman Refused Treatment By Doctor Because Of Her Weight

A clinically obese woman in Massachusetts has been refused medical treatment by a doctor due to her weight.

According to a report by the New York daily News, Ida Davidson who weighs over 200 pounds was recently told by her doctor that she would be unable to provide health care for her because of her obesity. Davidson was redirected instead to the UMASS Medical Center for the Clinically Obese for treatment.

Dr. Helen Carter, Davidson’s primary care physician explained that some of her employees had been injured while assisting obese patients. She has stated that the UMASS Medical Center for the Clinically Obese is better staffed, and has more appropriate resources for treating severely overweight patients.

Outrage and shock

Davidson admits to feeling outrage and shock at being told she was too heavy to be treated by her doctor. She confesses that at first, she couldn’t believe she was hearing Dr. Carter correctly. Davidson considers the whole situation to be ridiculous, and is quoted as saying “I thought doctors were there to help you”. She has since wondered whether she was simply too great a liability and too much work for her doctor.

Not illegal to refuse treatment due to obesity

The American Medical Association specifies that it is not illegal to turn down a patient because of their weight, and that there is absolute freedom for both doctors and patients to choose the person with whom they wish to engage in a doctor-patient relationship.

However, refusing to treat obese individuals produces a difficult situation for some physicians, and opinion is reportedly divided among the medical community. Many doctors prefer to try to work with persons suffering from excess weight in an effort to address the increasing problem of poor nutrition and a sedentary lifestyle which promotes obesity in American society.


Eating Disorder Self Test. Take the EAT-26 self test to see if you might have eating disorder symptoms that might require professional evaluation. All answers are confidential.

Find a Treatment Facility Near You

Click on a state below to find eating disorder treatment options that could be right for you.

How our helpline works

For those seeking addiction treatment for themselves or a loved one, the helpline is a private and convenient solution.

Calls to any general helpline (non-facility specific 1-8XX numbers) for your visit will be answered by American Addiction Centers (AAC).

We are standing by 24/7 to discuss your treatment options. Our representatives work solely for AAC and will discuss whether an AAC facility may be an option for you. Our helpline is offered at no cost to you and with no obligation to enter into treatment. Neither nor AAC receives any commission or other fee that is dependent upon which treatment provider a visitor may ultimately choose.

For more information on AAC’s commitment to ethical marketing and treatment practices, or to learn more about how to select a treatment provider, visit our About AAC page. If you wish to explore additional treatment options or connect with a specific rehab center, you can browse top-rated listings or visit SAMHSA.